32 replies to this topic

[Deathdwarf]

It looks not that bad of a card, but as a legendary you should set it to "Mythic Rare" rarity.

 

Gameplaywise:

 

It should rather be 4UUU than 3UUU because of its ability to take over other monsters (usually 6/6 for 3 colored and 3 colorless has not that strong abilities)

 

I think the sacrifice ability is fine, but maybe it should cost 4 or even 5 blue Mana instead of 3.

 

Trivia:

 

As I said, rather a Mythic Rare than a common.

 

I especially like the emblem of the deck, but not  the artwork. Probably something drawn would look better than this SSBM screenshot

 

In MtG, the second word after the big dash of a creature is considered the class and the first the race. To perfectly fix that, it would rather be "Legendary Creature - Pokemon Psychic" As a Pokemon Fan I know you would not say that and i would not recommend you to do that, but I just want to add it before those "OMG WORDING AND COLOR PIE AND TYPE CLASSIFICATION" Morons come out to blame you.

 

 

Nice card overall!

[Deathdwarf]

Yea, I see

To Moltres: I like this Anti-Green function, could be pretty nasty when playing your buddies' green decks >

Again, there is a little rarity failure right there

[Deathdwarf]

First off, you could just do the resistances and weaknesses with new rule paragraphs about Pokemon creatures and stuff.

 

 

Pokemon Type Colors

 

So, Pokemon has an own Card Game of course and you could just add in the brown fighting into red, but that would not really fit the color pie obviously.

 

I even thought about that myself and that is where I got to:

 

Normal is obviously colorless.

 

Fighting is about the fury of punching your enemy, that would be red.

 

Flying is a tough one, because it is either the Freedom (Red) or the Sky (White), I tend to bring it into White though.

 

Poison is about long lasting nasty damage effects, so it is Black.

 

Ground is either red because of the Mountains being the red symbol, or simply Colorless. Colorless is my personal favourite here.

 

Rock is the Hardness of Physical attacks, so it is Red.

 

Bug is Green - because Bug.

 

Ghost is either Black or Colorless, I would rather go with Black here.

 

Steel is either protection (White) or modern machinery (Blue). I tend to call it White, because Pokemon are no machines.

 

Fire is... well, guess. Red.

 

Water, even though it is not really fitting blue in a Knowledge way, it is a slow building and then booming Type, which fits Blue.

Grass is Green because of Nature and Growing and such, so it is Green.

 

Electro is tough again. It is either Modern Warfare (Blue) or Static Protection (White) or it is none of all (CL). I go with White IMO, but it is close.

 

Psychic is Blue because of that Magical thingy about it.

 

Ice is Blue just because Ice. It would rather be colorless, but Blue needs some Types and it is frozen Water. But it rather fits Colorless, I know.

 

Dragon is... guess, tough. They spit fire (red), they are superior creatures (green) and they know a lot of stuff (blue). I mostly go with Red.

 

Dark is Black obviously.

 

Fairy, the 6th Gen newcomer, sounds like a Green type so far.

 

 

 

Full list again:
 

COLORLESS

 

Normal

Ground

 

 

RED

 

Fire

Fighting

Rock

Dragon

 

 

BLUE

 

Water

Ice

Psychic

 

 

GREEN

 

Grass

Bug

Fairy

 

 

WHITE

 

Steel

Electric

Flying

 

 

BLACK
 

Dark

Ghost

Poison

 

 

 

Hope I could help you =)

[Deathdwarf]

Uhm, you are doing a little mistake there, according to Rule 520.5b: "A creature with toughness 0 or less is put into its owner’s graveyard. Regeneration can’t replace this event." - Magic rulebook as of its current version (9/9/13)

 

So you need to have at least a toughness of 1. If you want to simulate a creature with a toughness of zero, simply add a line like "This creature cannot deal damage by blocking." or something (My wording is horrible, but whatever).

[enesyugiohfan]

Shouldnt it be 'Normal pokemon.'?

[Deathdwarf]

Shouldnt it be 'Normal pokemon.'?

 

No, because Magic hates Pokemon. Race comes before the class, so Pokemon Normal

[Deathdwarf]

I think Rattata should cost at least 2, because of its First Strike.

 

To Ditto: I think its ability is too cheap. I am talking of WAY too cheap. Maybe it should be a 5 or 6 to make it predestined to beat up some big creatures.

[Deathdwarf]

I like Pikachu. The cards are fine as they are now.

 

 

Should I start putting the cards in spoiler tags?

 

It would come in handy once you completed an Evolution Line. But 150 Spoilers is not what you should go for xD.

[Deathdwarf]

To MissingNo: I have no problem with it, as MtG decks are limited to 60 cards so you will NEVER reach 99 mana.

To the Stadium: There are 2 card types that could be fitting:

Enchantment: The Enchantment is like a buff, like "All your creatures get +3/+3 while this card is in play.", an "Enchantment - Aura" only is enchanted to one single creature, but for this stadium, a normal Enchantment is more fitting.

 

Land: The obvious thingy. Lands are the regions the Planeswalkers (Players) come across during their journeys, remembering them in their libraries. The most common lands are the "Basic Lands" (Basic is like Legendary, a 'Supertype', a basic card is like the Unlimited mechanic in YGO and WoWTCG, you can put as many in your deck as you want), but also the more rare lands tend to cost no mana, so you would have a problem with making it cost 2.

 

But this is Custom Stuff, so... do whatever you want as I would do